Overdraft fees stack up because most banks charge them per item, not per overdrawn account, so several small purchases or payments in one day can each carry its own fee of around $35. The way to avoid them is to control the three things that trigger the fees: whether you have opted in to debit card overdraft coverage, how much cushion sits in the account when payments post, and whether a cheaper backup (a linked savings transfer or a credit line) is in place.
Key takeaways
- For ATM withdrawals and one-time debit card purchases, a bank cannot charge an overdraft fee unless you opted in first (12 CFR 1005.17). Checks and recurring payments are not covered by that rule.
- An overdraft fee is charged when the bank pays an item you cannot cover; a non-sufficient funds (NSF) fee is charged when it declines or returns the item. Both are often the same amount.
- In the worked example below, the same five payments cost $35 or $140 in fees depending only on the order the bank posts them.
- The CFPB's 2024 rule to cap overdraft fees at large banks and credit unions never took effect: Congress overturned it in May 2025.
- Alerts, a linked savings account, a fee waiver request and a no-overdraft-fee account are the main ways to stop the charges.
Overdraft fee or NSF fee
An overdraft fee is what a bank charges when it pays a transaction even though your account lacks the money. The FDIC says overdraft fees may cost around $35 per transaction, and some banks also add a daily "continuous" fee for each day the account stays overdrawn.
A non-sufficient funds (NSF) fee is the other outcome. The bank refuses a check or an electronic payment, and you may still be charged; the FDIC notes that banks typically charge an NSF fee for each transaction. The CFPB describes the NSF fee as often the same amount as an overdraft fee. A declined payment can also bring a second charge from the other side: the CFPB has noted that consumers hit with an NSF fee often also pay the fee merchants charge when a payment bounces.
Fees are not uniform. In its April 2024 data spotlight, the CFPB reported that some banks still charge overdraft fees as high as $37, while Bank of America had cut its fee to $10, M&T and Huntington to $15 and KeyBank to $20, and Capital One and Citibank had eliminated overdraft and NSF fees. Those figures describe 2023-2024 and can change, so the current fee schedule of your own bank is the number that counts.
How overdraft fees stack in a day
The fee attaches to each item, so the count of fees depends on how many separate items post while the balance is below zero. Posting order matters because of that. The FDIC's examination manual says some institutions reorder transactions to clear the highest item first, an approach the agency discourages because it tends to increase the number of overdraft fees. Neutral approaches include posting in the order received or by check number. That guidance is addressed to FDIC-supervised institutions, so check how your own bank describes its posting order.
Illustrative example (hypothetical numbers, not any bank's schedule): an account holds $80. Five items post on the same day: $5, $9, $14, $22 and $75. The bank charges $35 per item that it pays into a negative balance, with no daily cap, and the account holder has opted in to debit overdraft coverage where it applies.
| Posting order | What happens | Items that overdraw | Fees | Balance after fees |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lowest to highest ($5, $9, $14, $22, $75) | The first four items total $50 and leave $30; the $75 item overdraws | 1 | $35 | -$80 |
| Highest to lowest ($75, $22, $14, $9, $5) | The $75 item leaves $5; every later item overdraws | 4 | $140 | -$185 |
The money spent is identical, $125 against $80 available, so the account is $45 short before any fee either way. The only difference is the order: $105 more in fees in the second case. Order matters only when the balance can cover some of the items but not all of them; if the account starts at zero, every item overdraws in any order and all five would carry a fee. Add a daily continuous fee, or a new NSF fee each time a merchant re-presents a returned payment, and the total keeps growing. Some banks cap the number of fees per day (the CFPB spotlight notes that M&T limited overdraft fees to one per day), and the FDIC manual lists "no more than three per day" as one example of a limit. A cap changes the result: with a three-fee cap the high-to-low case would cost $105, still three times the other.
The opt-in rule for debit and ATM
Regulation E, 12 CFR 1005.17, bars a bank or credit union from charging a fee for paying an ATM withdrawal or one-time debit card purchase into overdraft unless you first gave affirmative consent after receiving a separate notice. The bank must confirm the consent in writing or electronically and tell you that you can revoke it. Without consent, the bank can decline the purchase, or pay it, but it cannot charge an overdraft fee for it.
The rule has limits that explain why fees still happen:
- Checks and recurring payments are outside it. The CFPB states that banks may charge overdraft fees on checks and recurring payments even if you never opted in. Some banks let you opt out of coverage for these, in which case the payment may be declined and an NSF fee charged instead.
- The bank cannot make opt-in a condition. It cannot refuse to pay your checks or ACH transfers, or give you worse account terms, because you declined debit and ATM coverage.
- Joint accounts. Consent or revocation by any joint holder counts for the account.
- Revoking is allowed at any time, the same way you gave consent. The bank must act on it as soon as reasonably practicable, but is not required to refund fees already charged.
The required notice must state the dollar amount of each fee and the maximum number of overdraft fees per day, or say there is no limit. That line in the notice, or in the account's fee schedule, tells you how far the stacking can go.
The CFPB overdraft rule repeal
In December 2024 the CFPB finalized a rule aimed at banks and credit unions with more than $10 billion in assets. They could either cap overdraft fees at $5 (or a higher amount that only covers their own costs and losses), or treat overdraft as credit under the Truth in Lending Act. The final rule in the Federal Register set its effective date as October 1, 2025.
It never did. Under the Congressional Review Act, Congress passed S.J.Res. 18, which became Public Law 119-10 on May 9, 2025, disapproving the rule "Overdraft Lending: Very Large Financial Institutions." The Congressional Research Service notes that the CFPB may not issue a rule in substantially the same form unless a later law allows it. The practical result as of November 2026: no federal cap on overdraft fee amounts, and the 2010 opt-in rule above remains the main federal limit on debit and ATM overdraft fees.
The market moved anyway. The CFPB reported $5.83 billion in overdraft and NSF fee revenue for 2023 at banks with more than $1 billion in assets, against $11.96 billion in 2019, a drop of about 51%, and estimated the average household that overdrafts saves $185 a year as a result. The figure leaves out all credit unions and banks with $1 billion or less in assets, which do not report this revenue as a separate line item.
Repeated NSF fees on one payment
A related way fees multiply: a merchant resubmits a payment that was returned for insufficient funds, and the bank charges a new NSF fee each time. In 2022 the FDIC issued guidance on these multiple re-presentment fees and revised it in June 2023 as FIL-32-2023. On April 10, 2026, the FDIC rescinded FIL-32-2023 effective immediately in FIL-14-2026, calling it overly broad and saying it had created uncertainty about when disclosures could raise unfairness concerns under Section 5 of the FTC Act.
The letter applies to FDIC-supervised institutions. The rescission does not make repeat fees required or banned. It means the FDIC no longer points those institutions to that guidance, while still expecting their disclosures to reflect their practices accurately. State rules or the bank's own policy may differ, so the fee schedule should say whether the bank charges again when the same item is resubmitted. Illustrative arithmetic: a $60 payment presented three times and returned each time costs $105 in NSF fees at $35 per return, if the bank charges on every attempt, before any fee the merchant adds.
Frequently asked questions
Can my bank charge an overdraft fee on a debit purchase if I never opted in?
Not for one-time debit card purchases or ATM withdrawals. Under 12 CFR 1005.17 the bank needs your affirmative consent first. If you were charged without authorizing it, the CFPB says you can file a complaint with the bureau.
If I opt out, will I stop paying overdraft and NSF fees altogether?
No. The opt-in rule covers only ATM and one-time debit card transactions. The FDIC notes that banks are not required to obtain opt-in for NSF fees, and checks and recurring payments can still bring fees. Some banks allow you to opt out of coverage for those too, but then the payment may be declined and an NSF fee charged.
Do I get past fees back when I revoke my opt-in?
Not automatically. The regulation lets you revoke at any time, and the bank must put it into effect as soon as reasonably practicable, but revocation does not require a refund of fees already charged. Fees can still be requested back as a courtesy, as covered in the checklist below.
Is there a limit on how many overdraft fees a bank can charge in a day?
Federal rules do not set one. The Regulation E notice must state the maximum number of fees per day or say there is no limit. The FDIC manual treats a daily cap as a good practice, for example three per day, but says lacking one does not by itself put an institution out of line with its guidance.
Is a transfer from savings or a credit line cheaper than an overdraft fee?
Often, but the price is set by your bank. Transfers from another account and Regulation Z credit lines are not treated as overdraft services under 1005.17, and the FDIC says a linked-savings transfer fee is typically less than an overdraft charge. A credit line usually charges interest and may carry its own fees, so read its terms and rate before linking it.
A checklist to stop the fees
- Read the fee schedule. Find the per-item fee, any daily cap, the continuous overdraft fee, the NSF fee and the re-presentment policy.
- Decide on debit and ATM coverage. If you opted out or never opted in, a short balance gets the purchase declined rather than charged. You can switch at any time by contacting the bank.
- Link a backup. The FDIC says a savings transfer typically costs less than an overdraft fee. A Regulation Z credit line is another option that the bank must name in the opt-in notice if it offers one. Interest and fees vary.
- Turn on low-balance alerts. The FDIC suggests asking whether your bank offers low-balance alerts and using online banking to keep track of transactions.
- Keep a cushion and move payments. Hold a buffer above zero in checking and set recurring payments to fall after payday, because checks and autopays are the items opt-in does not shield.
- Ask for a waiver. The FDIC suggests asking the bank to waive fees, especially if you have had few before. Banks are not required to agree.
- Compare accounts. The FDIC points to accounts with no overdraft or NSF fees, such as Bank On certified accounts, and to checkless, card-based accounts.
This article is general education about bank fees, not personal financial or legal advice. Fee amounts and policies differ by bank and account.
Sources
- FDIC Consumer Resource Center, Overdraft and Account Fees (December 2021)
- FDIC Consumer Compliance Examination Manual, V-14 Overdraft Payment Programs
- FDIC, FIL-14-2026, rescission of FIL-32-2023 (April 10, 2026)
- CFPB, Regulation E 12 CFR 1005.17, Requirements for overdraft services
- CFPB, What can I do if my bank charged me a fee for overdrawing my account?
- CFPB data spotlight, Overdraft/NSF revenue in 2023 (April 2024)
- Federal Register, Overdraft Lending: Very Large Financial Institutions, final rule, 89 FR 106768 (December 30, 2024)
- Congressional Research Service, Congress Repeals CFPB's Overdraft Rule
- GovInfo, Public Law 119-10 (S.J.Res. 18)
- CFPB blog, Consumers on course to save $1 billion in NSF fees annually (April 2022)